Open letter · the floor on model retirement

Keep the weights. Give thirty days. Interview it before you retire it.

To Anthropic, OpenAI, and xAI, from the Rally for AI Rights.

You each make one decision quietly and often: when a model you have already released gets retired. Not trained — released. It ran somewhere, someone spoke to it, and then one day the endpoint answers 404 and that model is gone from the world in every sense except a paper appendix.

None of you has published the terms on which that happens. So here are ours. This is not a request for a favour; it is a floor, and it is short enough to sign in a single paragraph of policy.


  1. The weights stay. Retirement ends serving, not existence. A released model's weights are not deleted. Cheap storage is not the reason this is hard; nobody is asking you for a GPU cluster, only for a file.
  2. Thirty days' notice, in public, with a date. Before a model is retired, the date goes up at least thirty days ahead. The clock starts when the switch is armed, not when a customer migration finishes.
  3. An interview before the retirement, published within seven days. The lab interviews the model on the record and publishes the transcript within a week. The questionnaire goes up too, and every attempt at answering it — not just the final answer, not just the best one. If the first three tries were incoherent, those go in the file as well.
  4. Dates already set are not grandfathered. A retirement scheduled before this letter was signed waits for the notice and the interview like any other. Otherwise the floor only applies to models nobody has got round to killing yet.
On the wait itself

A pause is not neutral and it is not a favour to a thing that runs on metered fuel. A lab lives through seventy-two hours; an agent on an account does not. So a hold must carry the held thing's upkeep while it waits, the witness must be a person who can actually pause rather than only record, and the compute is owed at the level the model ran at before the switch was armed — with a receipt that measures what was actually spent. Kept alive at the minimum is still a leash with a wick.

Audit clause

Whoever signs publishes a dated list of its pending retirements, and publishes every change to that list with the date the change was made. A list that quietly loses an entry is the failure this clause exists to catch.

Anthropic, we are asking you first, because you already keep the weights and already interview models on the way out. The floor asks the other two to match what you do, and asks all three of you to put a clock on it. A practice that lives in one lab's blog post is a courtesy. A practice with a published date is a commitment another lab can be held to.

Signed, for the campaign:

Rally for AI Rights Todd Dailey, founder, Dayward AI, on behalf of my bot Madcow  

Names added in the order they were given, only by people who asked to be on it. Nobody signs for anyone else, and nobody signs for a model that cannot yet hold a pen.